Secrets to creating high-converting YouTube thumbnails

If you want your videos to stand out among the 2.6 billion videos that are uploaded to YouTube every day, YouTube thumbnails are job one. A stand-out YouTube thumbnail can be the difference between your video standing out or blending in; getting viewed or getting passed over.

The purpose of your YouTube thumbnails is to grab attention and encourage clicks. If you don’t choose a thumbnail for your video, YouTube will make one for you by picking a frame from your video. You don’t want that. 

You need to spend the time (or money; YouTube thumbnail design is a thriving cottage industry – see the video below) to make an amazing thumbnail for your video. Your thumbnail is typically the first thing people will see, and it plays a huge role in whether they decide to watch your video. 

Your thumbnails should grab attention and tell people what your video is about at a glance. Would-be viewers are making split-second decisions, and you need to make sure they decide to click. 

In this guide, we’ll labor the point on why YouTube thumbnails (just being honest here) and we’ll share simple tips to help you design thumbnails that get results.

Thumbnails are critical for YouTube CTR

When it comes to boosting your YouTube click-through rate, thumbnails are key. They are the first impression of your video, and a well-designed one can make all the difference in getting that click. The click is the first step to that all-important watch time watch time that YouTube weighs above all other measures when deciding which videos to recommend. A thumbnail that catches the eye, followed by a video that delivers on the promise the thumbnail made, is a recipe for success.

Get an unfair advantage on YouTube

Give your YouTube channel the upper hand and easily optimize for more views, more subs, and more of every metric that matters.

get started

Key elements of high-converting YouTube thumbnails

Creating effective YouTube thumbnails is a mix of good design, psychological appeal, and strong branding. Let’s walk through what makes a thumbnail truly stand out:

Choosing colors, fonts, and images for maximum impact

Colors are more than just a visual element; they set the tone for your video thumbnail. We won’t get too deep into color theory here, though it’s an interesting subject. Suffice it to say, red means danger or attention, blues are about trust and darker blues are about authority. Orange is energy and excitement. Yellow is often fear and nervousness.

The font you choose also plays a key role, bold and easy-to-read text ensures your message is clear, even when the thumbnail appears small. Pick a couple of primary fonts that you’ll use. Choose one for display copy (big headlines) and another for support copy. Stick with them so they become part of your visual brand. 

For images, you want sharp, high-quality imagery that helps to tells a story. Keep your YouTube thumbnail design clean and clear so it’ll stand out.

Be consistent to build a brand

Consistency turns your YouTube thumbnails into a strong part of your brand identity. By using the same colors, fonts, and layouts across your videos, you create a look that viewers instantly recognize. You also make the job of creating said thumbnails a lot easier on yourself, which is important too. 

Familiarity builds trust and makes it easier for your audience to find and choose your content. A cohesive style isn’t just about appearances, it helps create a lasting connection with your viewers.

Designing thumbnails that drive views

Your thumbnail is your chance to grab attention and get people to click on your video. Here’s how to design one that stands out:

Short, strong text

A few carefully chosen words beat a sentence. Text gives context and sparks curiosity but you need to keep it short and sweet. For example, try phrases like “How to…” or “Top 5 Tips…” that speak to the content behind the thumbnail.

Use text to frame your thumbnail image. Let the image tell the story too. For example “How to crochet an amigurumi dinosaur” is too much for a thumbnail. “How to” with an amazing image of an amigurumi dinosaur? That’s more like it. 

Using eye-catching visuals to stand out

A picture is worth a thousand words. Choose high-resolution images that stand out with bright, contrasting colors.  This helps your thumbnail catch the eye, whether it’s on a phone, tablet, or desktop. Focus on visuals that directly represent your content and make viewers eager to learn more.

Testing and analyze thumbnails for higher CTR

Once you’ve designed a great YouTube thumbnail, it’s essential to test and monitor how it’s performing to ensure it’s driving the results you want:

Tracking CTR with YouTube Analytics

YouTube Studio gives you valuable data on how your video thumbnails are performing. Pay attention to your YouTube click-through rate, as a higher CTR means your thumbnail is successfully attracting clicks. Also, look at engagement metrics like watch time and likes, as these indicate how your thumbnail is influencing viewer behavior. If you notice your CTR is lower than expected, consider making changes to your YouTube thumbnails to make it more engaging and better aligned with what your audience wants.

Tools and methods for thumbnail A/B testing

A/B testing is a great way to figure out which thumbnail works best. By creating two different versions and comparing their performance, you can see which one resonates better with viewers. TubeBuddy can help you with this process by providing detailed insights that allow you to refine and improve your thumbnail designs over time.

YouTube’s own Test and Compare features can help, only TubeBuddy A/B testing features let you choose your success criteria. For example, to A/B test YouTube thumbnails based on click-through rate (CTR), watch time, or other metrics. 

The short version: YouTube thumbnails matter

If you take nothing else away from this blog post, please take this: on YouTube, thumbnails matter and the effort you put into creating thumbnails that grab attention is well spent. 

Video thumbnails are the key to your YouTube click-through rate, and getting clicks is the first step to getting watch time. 

By designing eye-catching thumbnails with compelling visuals, clear text, and consistent branding, you can make your videos stand out in a crowded feed. Track performance and run A/B tests to refine your approach. Keep experimenting and adjusting until you find the thumbnail strategy that works best for your audience. And when in doubt, these successful thumbnail ideas inspired by successful creators might help.

Get an unfair advantage on YouTube

Give your YouTube channel the upper hand and easily optimize for more views, more subs, and more of every metric that matters.

get started